Why Does Interviewer Ask This Question?

An interviewer may ask “How would you handle a situation where you disagreed with a decision made by your manager” to assess a candidate’s ability to handle conflicts, navigate difficult situations and make strategic decisions. This question aims to understand the candidate’s approach when dealing with conflicts, and disagreements and how they handle situations where they are not aligned with their manager’s decision.

In most cases, an interviewer would want to understand the candidate’s perspective on how they would handle the situation when they disagree with the decision made by their manager. They want to know how the candidate would communicate their disagreement, how they would manage their working relationship with their manager and how they would ultimately come to a compromise or solution that is beneficial for the company.

Additionally, the interviewer is also trying to gauge the candidate’s ability to think critically and independently and respect the hierarchy and management. A good employee knows when to voice their opinion, but also when to trust the judgement of their manager and align with the decision.

By asking this question, the interviewer is also looking for how well the candidate can handle difficult and challenging situations, and how they can make strategic decisions that are beneficial for the company. It’s important to demonstrate your ability to communicate effectively, find common ground, and make decisions that are in the best interest of the company.

Also, Check – 100 Situational Questions For The Interview

5 Tips To Answer This Question

1. Emphasize Your Communication Skills: Effective communication is key when dealing with a situation where you disagree with a decision made by your manager. Be prepared to share specific examples of how you have effectively communicated your disagreements in the past and how you came to a compromise or solution that was beneficial for the company.
2. Show Your Ability To Think Critically: In an interview, you can highlight your ability to think critically and independently by providing an example of a time when you disagreed with a decision and how you were able to find a creative solution.
3. Stress The Importance Of Aligning With The Company’s Goals: It’s important to stress that while you may disagree with a decision, you are always focused on aligning with the company’s goals and making decisions that are in the best interest of the company.
4. Show Your Willingness To Compromise: Highlight your ability to find common ground and to compromise. Share examples of how you were able to find a solution that was beneficial for both you and the company.
5. Show Your Respect For Hierarchy: Even if you disagree, you should always respect the hierarchy, demonstrate that you can trust the judgement of your manager, and explain how you would work to implement the decision. Show that you understand the importance of maintaining a positive relationship with your manager and the rest of the team.

Things To Avoid While Answering This Question

1. Avoid Being Confrontational Or Aggressive: When answering this question in an interview, it’s important to remain professional and avoid any confrontational or aggressive language when discussing or disagreeing with a decision made by your manager. This can come across as unprofessional and may negatively impact your chance of being selected for the role.
2. Avoid Blaming Or Criticizing Your Manager: Even if you disagree with a decision, it’s important to avoid blaming or criticizing your manager. This can come across as unprofessional and unproductive and may damage the working relationship with your manager.
3. Avoid Being Inflexible Or Unwilling To Compromise: When disagreeing with a decision, it’s important to be open to other possibilities and to be willing to compromise to find a solution that is beneficial for both you and the company. Avoid showing that you are inflexible or unwilling to consider different options or to make adjustments.
4. Avoid Being Overly Critical: It’s important to highlight your ability to think critically, but also to be aware of how critical you are. Being overly critical can come across as negative and may not be viewed positively by the interviewer
5. Avoid Giving Vague Or General Answers: When answering this question in an interview, it’s important to be specific and provide concrete examples of how you have handled similar situations in the past. Avoid giving vague or general answers, as this can make it difficult for the interviewer to assess your qualifications for the role.

Also, Check – Important Interview Etiquette You All Need To Know

How To Answer “How Would You Handle A Situation Where You Disagreed With A Decision Made By Your Manager” In An Interview?

When answering the question “How would you handle a situation where you disagreed with a decision made by your manager” in an interview, it’s important to demonstrate your ability to communicate effectively, think critically and make decisions that are in the best interest of the company while also showing respect for the hierarchy. Here are some steps you can take to answer this question effectively:

• Start by outlining your approach to disagreeing with a decision made by your manager. Highlight your communication skills and explain how you would express your disagreement in a professional and respectful manner.

• Share specific examples of similar situations you have encountered in the past, and explain the steps you took, the outcome, and the positive results that came out of it.

• Emphasize the importance of aligning with the company’s goals and making decisions that are in the best interest of the company. Share your understanding that even if you disagree with a decision, it is important to work together to implement it.

• Highlight your ability to find common ground and to compromise, and share examples of how you were able to find a solution that was beneficial for both you and the company.

• Convey your willingness to respect the hierarchy and trust the judgement of your manager. Share your understanding that even if you disagree with a decision, it’s important to maintain a positive working relationship with your manager and the rest of the team.

• finally, it’s important to present yourself as a professional, a good communicator and a team player. Show your ability to manage conflicts, navigate difficult situations and make strategic decisions that are beneficial for the company. Also, stress that you understand the importance of keeping the company’s best interest in mind.

Also, Check – What To Wear For a Job-interview

Example

1. Answer: “I would first try to understand the reasoning behind the decision and see if there are any alternative solutions that could address the situation. I would then express my disagreement in a professional and tactful manner, making sure to keep the company’s best interest in mind. I would work to find a solution that is mutually beneficial for both myself and the company.”
2. Answer: “If I were to disagree with a decision made by my manager, I would approach the situation by first building a positive and professional relationship with my manager. I would actively listen to their concerns and try to understand their perspective. I would then communicate my concerns and work together to find a solution that would benefit the company.”
3. Answer: “I would handle the situation by first gathering more information and data to make sure that I have a clear understanding of the situation. Then, I would have an open and honest conversation with my manager, express my concerns, and work together to come to a compromise that aligns with the company’s goals.”
4. Answer: “In case of disagreement, I would first take time to understand the reasoning behind the decision and the intended outcomes. Then I would express my disagreement in a tactful and respectful manner, highlighting alternative solutions or perspectives that could be considered. I would look for a way to align the decision with the company’s goals and objectives.”
5. Answer: “My approach would be to first understand the situation and the reasoning behind the decision made by my manager. I would then express my disagreement in a professional and respectful manner, focusing on the facts and not on personal opinions. I would work with my manager to find a solution that is beneficial for both myself and the company.”